We accept all insurance — no DRP contractsCall (602) 600-7825

Blog · Insurance

What should I do if the insurance estimate is too low to fix my car?

If your insurance company's initial repair estimate is lower than the actual cost of repairs, you do not have to settle for a cheap, incomplete fix. You have the right to have your vehicle restored to its pre-accident condition using safe, proper repair methods.

Why is the insurance estimate so much lower than the body shop's estimate?

Insurance companies write initial estimates based on visual damage only, often using photos from an app, which completely misses hidden structural and mechanical issues. Their goal is to write the lowest possible initial estimate to limit their financial exposure, frequently specifying cheap aftermarket parts and cutting corners on labor times. An independent body shop, on the other hand, performs a complete teardown to identify all underlying damage, including compromised structural frames and misaligned ADAS sensors.

How does the supplement process cover the difference in repair costs?

The supplement process is how a body shop submits documentation of hidden damage and actual parts costs to the insurance company to secure additional payment. Once our technicians disassemble your vehicle, we document every piece of hidden damage, photograph the proof, and submit a supplemental invoice directly to the insurer. Because Airpark Auto Collision works for you—not the insurance company—we refuse to cut corners and will fight to ensure the insurer pays for every necessary repair step.

If you received a lowball estimate from an insurance adjuster, bring your vehicle to Airpark Auto Collision at 22039 N 24th Ave Ste A, Phoenix, AZ or call us at (602) 600-7825. We will handle the supplemental claim process from start to finish to ensure your vehicle is repaired safely and correctly.

Can an insurance company force me to use a shop that accepts their low estimate?

No, Arizona law prevents insurance companies from steering you to a specific repair facility or forcing you to use their preferred network shops. You have the absolute right to choose any independent collision repair shop you trust. While insurance direct repair program (DRP) shops might agree to the insurer's cheap repair methods to keep their contract, an independent shop like ours advocates solely for your safety and vehicle value.

  • We document all hidden structural damage missed by the initial photo estimate.
  • We advocate for original equipment manufacturer (OEM) parts over cheap aftermarket alternatives.
  • We perform necessary ADAS safety calibrations that insurers often try to omit.
  • We handle all negotiations and paperwork with the insurance adjuster directly.

Common Questions

Do I have to pay the difference if the insurance estimate is lower than your shop's estimate?

No, you are generally not responsible for the difference as long as the repairs are necessary and covered by your policy. Our team submits a supplemental claim to the insurance company to cover the additional parts, labor, and safety procedures required to restore your vehicle properly. We resolve these discrepancies directly with the insurer so you only pay your deductible.

Why do insurers write estimates based on photos?

Photo-based estimating apps are designed to save insurance companies time and money, but they rarely capture the full extent of collision damage. Bumper covers and plastic panels often hide bent frames, broken brackets, and damaged suspension components that can only be seen during a physical teardown. We perform a complete physical inspection to ensure your vehicle is structurally sound.

What if the insurance company refuses to pay for OEM parts?

We fight the insurer on your behalf by providing documentation that aftermarket parts do not meet the structural or safety specifications of your vehicle. While policy terms vary, we advocate aggressively for OEM parts to maintain your vehicle's safety standards and resale value, especially for drivers in North Phoenix and the TSMC corridor.

Call Airpark Before You Make a Decision

If your insurance company is telling you where to take your car, your vehicle is sitting in an impound lot, or your claim is being delayed — call us first. We'll explain your options.